New York City
Line-up
- 1Johnson, Sean
- 5S. Ibeagha
- 4Chanot, Maxime
- 16J. Sands
- 26Acevedo, Nicolas
- 11V. Castellanos
- 19J. Medina
- 2Gloster, Chris
- 12M. Amundsen
- 10Moralez, Maxi
- 15T. Rocha
- 17Ismael Tajouri
- 20G. Þórarinsson
- 55K. Parks
- 21A. Jasson
Subs
- 13L. Barraza
- 25C. Mizell
- 24Gray, Tayvon
- 32V. Latinovich
- 80J. Haak
Columbus Crew
Line-up
- 1E. Room
- 3J. Williams
- 4Mensah, Jonathan
- 6Nagbe, Darlington
- 7Pedro Santos
- 10L. Zelarayán
- 12Diaz, Luis
- 11Zardes, Gyasi
- 26S. Abdul-Salaam
- 18L. Fraser
- 20A. Mățan
- 14W. Francis
- 25Harrison Afful
- 8Artur
Subs
- 24Evan Bush
- 30Keita, Aboubacar
- 5V. Wormgoor
- 16I. Parente
- 99Wright-Phillips, Bradley
